Hi ..
NaOH in powder form didn't work for me neither, I mixed it with drain cleaner and that made it ..
Just powdery NaOH gave me a non flammable gas too! Or a long time for the reaction to start ..
Or maybe we didn't have the right kind of NaOH powder ..
My Aluminum is very impure and it's working ! .. I even use Coke Cans that are painted and it's working .. .